熊猫体育

Addressing calls to collapse 熊猫体育鈥檚 dual-listed companies structure

Benefits of a dual-listed companies structure


We operate under a dual-listed companies (DLC) structure. 熊猫体育 plc is incorporated in the UK and listed on the London Stock Exchange with ADRs listed on the New York Stock Exchange, and 熊猫体育 Limited is incorporated in Australia and listed on the Australian Securities Exchange.

Palliser Capital initially called for 熊猫体育 to collapse our DLC structure under a single Australian entity in May 2024, and subsequently together with certain other shareholders in December 2024, submitted a resolution for an independent review of the structure. That resolution, outlined in the Notice of Meeting, will be voted on during the 2025 annual general meetings of 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited.

Dual-listed company structure

Collapsing our DLC is expected to result in:

Tax costs

in the mid-single digit US$B

Unified share price

Likely trending to levels significantly lower than the 熊猫体育 Limited share price before DLC collapse

Wasted franking credits

熊猫体育 is unlikely to be able to pay fully franked dividends to Australian holders in the longer term

The Board’s recommendation is that shareholders vote against Resolution 21 at the 熊猫体育 Limited AGM. We also recommended that shareholders vote against Resolution 24 at the 熊猫体育 plc AGM, held on 3 April 2025.

How to vote

Shareholders can  and follow the prompts. To use this facility you will need your Shareholder Reference Number (SRN) or Holder Identification Number (HIN), postcode and control number as shown on your proxy form.

Proxy appointments submitted through this site must be received by 9:30am (AWST) on Tuesday, 29 April 2025.

To vote in line with the Board’s unanimous recommendation, you should mark against for Resolution 21 as follows:

How to vote

Our response to Palliser Capital鈥檚 resolution

Our full Board, including independent non-executive directors, undertook a comprehensive review of the DLC structure during 2024, as it does on a periodic basis. They assessed arguments for and against collapsing our DLC with the support of leading external financial and legal advisers, including detailed tax analysis by professional services firm EY.

After carefully considering the review鈥檚 findings, the Board concluded that:

  1. The DLC structure continues to be effective in providing benefits to 熊猫体育 and its shareholders
  2. DLC collapse would destroy value for our shareholders

Collapsing our DLC would be expected to result in:

  • Tax costs in the mid-single digit US$ billions
  • The share price of a unified 熊猫体育 trending down towards the weighted average of the 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited share prices, which on average during 2024 was c.14% below the 熊猫体育 Limited share price
  • Significant wastage of franking credits, with 熊猫体育 being unable to pay fully franked dividends to Australian holders in the longer term

Given the findings of the 2024 review, the Board unanimously believes that the resolution is highly duplicative and unnecessary. There is no basis for expecting that an additional review, including an independent expert report, would lead to a different conclusion.

The resolution also requires the formation of a committee to review a collapse of the DLC structure, with an external shareholder representative in attendance; this would be a clear deviation from established governance principles.

Learn more about why the resolution is against our shareholders鈥 best interests in the . You can also read the notices of meeting for the  and the .

The Board鈥檚 comprehensive review concluded that collapsing our DLC would likely negatively impact shareholder value in the following key areas:

Wasted franking credits

DLC collapse could adversely impact the individual tax position of tax-resident Australian shareholders and the 熊猫体育 share price in due course.

  • DLC unification is expected to result in significant 鈥渨astage鈥 of franking credits in the future given the >3x increase in franked dividends that would be paid to 熊猫体育 shareholders, a large portion of whom would not be expected to benefit from them as they would not be tax-resident in Australia
  • This would likely leave 熊猫体育 unable to pay fully franked dividends in the longer term
  • The DLC structure means 熊猫体育 can use franking credits more efficiently, preserving this benefit for Australian shareholders

The DLC structure provides for the efficient use of franking credits -

by allowing for the payment of franked dividends to only 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders who are more likely to be Australian tax-resident

Dual-listed company structure
1熊猫体育 plc currently represents 77% of the voting rights of the DLC, and 熊猫体育 Limited currently represents 23% of the voting rights of the DLC. Not all 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders currently benefit from franking credits because only Australian tax-resident shareholders of 熊猫体育 Limited benefit from franking credits. Following a unification, the proportion of Australian tax-resident shareholders holding unified 熊猫体育 shares may change

Falling share price

The Board believes that following a DLC collapse, it is highly unlikely that the 熊猫体育 Limited share price would be maintained at pre-collapse levels and that it is more likely to trend towards the weighted average of the 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited share prices. On average during 2024 this was c.14% below the 熊猫体育 Limited share price.

Approximately US$40bn of additional incremental demand would be needed from Australian tax-resident shareholders to avoid this – this is significantly more than the average annual equity capital markets issuance in Australia over the last 10 years – at US$27.5bn.

Collapsed 熊猫体育 share price is more likely to move towards the weighted average

Dual-listed company unified share price effect

Source: FactSet as of 28 February 2025. Share prices shown in A$.

Board Response to Plc AGM Resolution 24 / Ltd AGM Resolution 21
PDF
425 KB
Letter from the Chairman
PDF
135 KB

Benefits of a dual-listed companies structure

What are the advantages of 熊猫体育鈥檚 DLC structure? It delivers shareholder value.

1. Access to global markets

  • The DLC structure provides access to significant depth of liquidity in demand for, and trading of, 熊猫体育 shares.
  • This is achieved through primary listings and premium index inclusion in 2 major capital markets and mining investment centres.
  • 熊猫体育 plc has a pre-eminent position in the UK market as the default investment in the mining sector.
  • 熊猫体育 plc is one of the 10 largest companies and top 5 dividend payers in the FTSE-100 index.

2. Above industry average shareholder returns

  • Since implementing our shareholders returns policy in 2016, we have consistently delivered cash returns to shareholders at the upper end of the 40% to 60% range, in line with or above key peers.
  • Total cash returns to shareholders over the longer term are expected to be in the range of 40% to 60% of underlying earnings in aggregate through the cycle.

3. Franking credit tax benefits

  • The DLC structure means we can use franking credits more efficiently.
  • 熊猫体育 Limited has paid fully franked dividends to shareholders since the DLC structure formed in 1995 and will continue to do so in the long term under the DLC structure. 
  • However, we expect a DLC collapse would result in a significant "wastage" of franking credits and may adversely affect the share price of a unified 熊猫体育. 
  • A unified 熊猫体育 may be unable to pay fully franked dividends in the longer term, which may adversely affect the individual tax position of Australian shareholders.

Learn more about 熊猫体育鈥檚 dual-listed companies structure.

  • wave

Dual-listed companies structure

The 熊猫体育 Group consists of 熊猫体育 plc, which is registered in England and Wales, and 熊猫体育 Limited, which is registered in Australia.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main benefits of maintaining the DLC structure?

Following the extensive review conducted in 2024, the Board unanimously concluded that the DLC structure continues to be effective and provide benefits to 熊猫体育 and our shareholders.

The DLC provides access to significant depth of liquidity through primary listings and premium index inclusion in 2 major capital markets and mining investment centres, with a pre-eminent position in the UK market.

The DLC provides flexibility to raise capital, pursue strategic mergers and acquisitions (M&A), and deliver shareholder returns – in fact, we have undertaken these activities several times in the past. 

The DLC structure also enables a more efficient utilisation of franking credits. 

Have we delivered under the DLC structure?

Over the 30-year period since the inception of the DLC structure to 31 December 2024, 熊猫体育 plc has outperformed the FTSE 100 and 熊猫体育 Limited has outperformed the ASX 200 – both in terms of share price performance as well as on a total shareholder return basis.

Over the last 9 years, we have consistently delivered shareholder returns at the upper end of our 40-60% underlying earnings guidance range.

The DLC structure also fully supports our shareholder returns policy with 熊猫体育 plc being one of the top 5 dividend payers in the FTSE-100. 

Has the Board engaged thoroughly on this issue?

The Board undertook a comprehensive review of the DLC structure during 2024 with substantial input and advice from leading external financial and legal advisers, including detailed tax analysis undertaken by professional services firm EY.

The Company has also held 7 meetings with Palliser Capital, including with our Chairman, CEO and CFO.

Throughout 2024 and 2025, until now, we have been, and will keep, engaging openly with all our shareholders on this topic and will be open to any feedback. 

How recently has the Board undertaken a review into the DLC structure and has this review been supported by any 3rd parties?

The Board undertook a comprehensive review of the DLC structure during 2024 with substantial input and advice from leading external financial and legal advisers, including detailed tax analysis undertaken by professional services firm EY.

Following this comprehensive review, the unanimous conclusion of the Board continues to be that the DLC structure should be retained. The DLC structure continues to be effective and provides benefits to 熊猫体育 and our shareholders, while unification under 熊猫体育 Limited would be value destructive and against the best interests of shareholders and 熊猫体育 as a whole.

What are franking credits, and how can I benefit from them?

Franking credits are tax credits available to shareholders which arise from Australian corporate tax paid on profits generated by 熊猫体育 Limited’s Australian assets. Franking credits are available only to 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders that are Australian residents for the purposes of tax. They enable such shareholders to reduce the tax on dividends (up to a maximum rate of 30%).

Franking credits provide an exemption from Australian dividend withholding tax if payable to shareholders who are not tax residents in Australia but cannot otherwise be utilised by such shareholders.

Franking credits are therefore effectively wasted in the hands of a non-Australian resident shareholder.
Under a unified structure, franking credits would be attached to all dividends, meaning a significant wastage, because non-Australian shareholders cannot use the credits “given to them”.

83% of the investor base of the combined ownership of the Group (both 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited) is located outside Australia.

To understand if franking credits are available to you or if you can benefit from them, you should seek independent legal and tax advice tailored to your circumstances.

How would unification impact the distribution of franking credits versus how they are currently distributed?

Franking credits are currently distributed to 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders only through the dividend paid by 熊猫体育 Limited.

Under a unified structure, instead of franking credits just being distributed to existing 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders, the credits would be attached to all dividends, meaning a significant wastage as non-Australian tax resident shareholders cannot use them.

In addition, the Board does not believe that 熊猫体育 would be able to pay fully franked dividends in the longer term under a unified structure under 熊猫体育 Limited.

Why is our DLC structure different to those of other previous DLCs? 

Every DLC structure is different and are a feature of how the businesses came together, the geographical locations of the businesses with significant assets, and the distribution of shareholders on each side of the DLC structure. In short, no DLC structure is the same and therefore the advantages and disadvantages of unification will differ between them.

What would the tax implications be of unification under the Limited line? 

According to detailed analysis undertaken by external professional services firm EY, unification would generate one-off tax costs of mid-single-digit billions of US dollars. 

What should investors keep in mind when comparing the Grant Thornton report commissioned by Palliser and the analysis conducted by 熊猫体育 and our external financial advisors, including EY?  

The Grant Thornton desktop report merely advances Palliser’s previously published arguments. Our Board had already considered these arguments as part of the in-depth DLC unification review.

Importantly, Grant Thornton’s desktop report, and its conclusions, relied on publicly available information. In its assessment of the tax costs of unification, Grant Thornton relied on the assessment of Palliser Capital’s own undisclosed “independent” tax advisor and publicly available information.

We note that the Grant Thornton report neither provides any supporting evidence to back up Palliser’s assertions regarding the alleged US$50 billion value destruction, nor addresses this argument at all.

We also note that the report comes with major caveats and disclaimers, such as to not rely on it, and was further commissioned and paid for by Palliser.

Why can’t we publish the EY review of unification tax costs? 

It is neither appropriate nor customary to publish detailed tax analyses as they contain confidential and highly commercially sensitive information, which would be materially prejudicial to the interests of 熊猫体育 and our shareholders if made public. 

Is the DLC structure an impediment on us undertaking strategic mergers and acquisitions (M&A)? 

The DLC structure provides us with the ability to offer equity in either 熊猫体育 plc or 熊猫体育 Limited to raise capital or use as share consideration in acquisitions. This gives 熊猫体育 flexibility to execute strategic M&A. Since the formation of the DLC structure, 熊猫体育 has undertaken strategic M&A using stock and/or cash. In each case 熊猫体育 carefully evaluates all acquisition funding options to deliver the optimal outcome for shareholders. The DLC structure does not prevent share-based acquisitions, as demonstrated by previous transactions by DLC acquirers, including 熊猫体育’s acquisition of Comalco, 熊猫体育’s acquisition of Ashton and BHP Billiton’s proposed acquisition of 熊猫体育.

Why are you recommending that shareholders vote against the resolution? 

The Board undertook a comprehensive review of the DLC structure during 2024, assessing the arguments for and against unification. The review included substantial input and advice from leading external financial and legal advisers, including detailed tax analysis undertaken by professional services firm EY. 

The Board carefully considered the findings of the review and unanimously concluded that the DLC structure continues to be effective and provide benefits to 熊猫体育 and our shareholders.

Given the rigorous process undertaken and the findings of the review in 2024, the Board believes that the proposed review requested by Palliser would be highly duplicative, and that unification is not in the best interests of shareholders and 熊猫体育 as a whole.

The resolution requires the formation of a committee to review a unification of the DLC structure, with an external shareholder representative in attendance, which marks a clear deviation from established governance principles.

熊猫体育’s directors therefore unanimously recommend that you vote AGAINST Resolution 24 at the 熊猫体育 plc AGM and Resolution 21 at the 熊猫体育 Limited AGM.

.

Why doesn’t the Board just allow an independent review of the DLC structure and settle the question once and for all?  

The Board undertook a comprehensive review of the DLC structure during 2024, assessing the arguments for and against unification. The review included substantial input and advice from leading external financial and legal advisers, including detailed tax analysis undertaken by professional services firm EY. 

The Board unanimously concluded that the DLC structure continues to be effective and provide benefits to 熊猫体育 and our shareholders, while unification would destroy value to shareholders.

Given the rigorous process undertaken and the findings of the review in 2024, the Board firmly believes that a further review as proposed by the resolution would be highly duplicative and unnecessary.

It would also divert significant company resources and time away from critical focus on strategy execution (such as integrating the recently acquired Arcadium Lithium). 

Why is this proposal going to be voted on by both PLC and Limited shareholders? 

We are putting forward this proposal as a Joint Decision Matter to be voted on by both 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders following a clarification from Palliser Capital on their original submission that their intention had been to have this voted on at each meeting.

This does not change the Board’s recommendation that shareholders vote against the resolution. 

Following the differing recommendations from the Proxy advisers, what is the Board’s perspective?

熊猫体育’s directors continue to unanimously recommend that you vote against Resolution 24 at the 熊猫体育 plc AGM and Resolution 21 at the 熊猫体育 Limited AGM. 

The Board undertook a comprehensive review of the DLC structure during 2024, assessing the arguments for and against unification. The review included substantial input and advice from leading external financial and legal advisers, including detailed tax analysis undertaken by professional services firm EY.  

The Board carefully considered the findings of the review and unanimously concluded that the DLC structure continues to be effective and provide benefits to 熊猫体育 and our shareholders. A further review of a DLC unification is duplicative and would divert company resources and time away from critical focus on strategy execution. 

Also, the Resolution requires the formation of a committee to review a unification of the DLC structure, despite the full Board, with all independent directors, having done so, with an “external shareholder representative” in attendance. This marks a clear deviation from established governance principles and fundamentally risks undermining the Board’s role.

How does the issue of unification differ when comparing 熊猫体育 with BHP, which unified its DLC structure in 2022? 

The rationale for BHP’s unification does not apply to 熊猫体育 for several reasons, including the location, growth outlook tax profile of the Group’s assets, and the scale of the entity to be absorbed by the acquiring entity in a DLC unification under the Limited company. These fundamental differences impact both up-front execution of any DLC unification and long-term shareholder value. 

What is the process for a Joint Decision Matter and when will the result be announced? 

A Joint Decision Matter enables shareholders of 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited to vote as a joint electorate.

The results of the resolution will be determined when the relevant polls are closed at the end of the 熊猫体育 Limited meeting, scheduled for 1 May 2025.

The results of the resolution will be announced to the relevant stock exchanges and posted on our website after that date.

As an investor what should I do?

The Board undertook a comprehensive review of the DLC structure during 2024, assessing the arguments for and against unification. The review included substantial input and advice from leading external financial and legal advisers, including detailed tax analysis undertaken by professional services firm EY. 

The Board unanimously concluded that the DLC structure continues to be effective and provide benefits to 熊猫体育 and our shareholders, whilst unification would be value destructive to shareholders and against the best interests of shareholders and 熊猫体育 as a whole.

The Board’s recommendation is that shareholders vote against the resolution. 

How do I vote on this Resolution?

Details on how to attend and vote are set out in the notices of meetings for the 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited annual general meetings.

Shareholders who are unable to participate in the meeting are strongly encouraged to complete and submit a proxy form. For 熊猫体育 plc shareholders, proxy forms must be submitted by no later than 11:00am (BST) on Tuesday, 1 April 2025. For 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders, proxy forms must be submitted by no later than 9:30am (AWST) on Tuesday, 29 April 2025. Submitting a proxy form will ensure your vote is recorded, but does not prevent you from participating and voting at the meeting either in person, or online. 

The notices of meeting contain further information on how to submit a proxy form and attend the meeting.

Why did the Board not put this to Limited holders initially?

The Board had understood Palliser intended for its requisition to be put to 熊猫体育 plc shareholders only, given it was submitted to 熊猫体育 plc with reference to its Annual General Meeting only.  Once Palliser clarified this was not its intent, the Board agreed that it was appropriate to put forward the resolution to both 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited shareholders at their respective annual general meetings.

  • Cautionary and supporting statements 

    This webpage has been prepared by 熊猫体育 plc and 熊猫体育 Limited (together with their subsidiaries, “熊猫体育”).  

    By accessing this webpage, you acknowledge that you have read and understood the following statements.
  • Forward-looking statements 

    This webpage includes “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. All statements other than statements of historical facts included on this webpage, including, without limitation, those regarding 熊猫体育’s financial position, business strategy, plans and objectives of management for future operations (including development plans and objectives relating to 熊猫体育’s products, production forecasts and reserve and resource positions), are forward-looking statements. The words “intend”, “aim”, “project”, “anticipate”, “estimate”, “plan”, “believes”, “expects”, “may”, “should”, “will”, “target”, "considers", "would", "continue", “set to” or similar expressions, commonly identify such forward-looking statements. 

    Such forward-looking statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors which may cause the actual results, performance or achievements of 熊猫体育, or industry results, to be materially different from any future results, performance or achievements expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements, particularly in light of the current economic climate. Such forward-looking statements are prospective in nature and are not based on historical facts, but rather on current expectations and on numerous assumptions regarding 熊猫体育’s present and future business strategies and the environment in which 熊猫体育 will operate in the future. Among the important factors that could cause 熊猫体育’s actual results, performance or achievements to differ materially from those in the forward-looking statements include, but are not limited to: an inability to live up to 熊猫体育’s values and any resultant damage to its reputation; the impacts of geopolitics on trade and investment; the impacts of climate change and the transition to a low-carbon future; an inability to successfully execute and/or realise value from acquisitions and divestments; the level of new ore resources, including the results of exploration programmes and/or acquisitions; disruption to strategic partnerships that play a material role in delivering growth, production, cash or market positioning; damage to 熊猫体育’s relationships with communities and governments; an inability to attract and retain requisite skilled people; declines in commodity prices and adverse exchange rate movements; an inability to raise sufficient funds for capital investment; inadequate estimates of ore resources and reserves; delays or overruns of large and complex projects; changes in tax regulation; safety incidents or major hazard events; cyber breaches; physical impacts from climate change; the impacts of water scarcity; natural disasters; an inability to successfully manage the closure, reclamation and rehabilitation of sites; the impacts of civil unrest; the impacts of the Ukraine conflict; breaches of 熊猫体育’s policies, standard and procedures, laws or regulations; trade tensions between the world’s major economies; increasing societal and investor expectations, in particular with regard to environmental, social and governance considerations; the impacts of technological advancements; and such other risks identified in 熊猫体育’s most recent Annual Report and accounts in Australia and the United Kingdom and the most recent Annual Report on Form 20-F, which was filed with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) on February 20, 2025, or Form 6-Ks furnished to, or filed with, the SEC. If any one or more of these risks or uncertainties materialises or if any one or more of the assumptions prove incorrect, actual results may differ materially from those expected, estimated or projected. Forward-looking statements should, therefore, be construed in light of such risk factors and undue reliance should not be placed on forward-looking statements. Actual results, performance or achievements may differ materially from those expressed or implied in those statements and any projections and assumptions on which these statements are based. These statements may assume the success of 熊猫体育’s business strategies, the success of which may not be realised within the period for which the forward-looking statements may have been prepared, or at all. No guarantee, representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy, likelihood of achievement or reasonableness of any forward-looking statements contained on this webpage. All subsequent oral or written forward-looking statements attributable to 熊猫体育 or any of its respective associates, directors, officers, employees or advisers, are expressly qualified in their entirety by the cautionary statement above. 熊猫体育 expressly disclaims any obligation or undertaking (except as required by applicable law, the UK Listing Rules, the Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules of the Financial Conduct Authority and the Listing Rules of the Australian Securities Exchange) to release publicly any updates or revisions to any forward-looking statement contained herein to reflect any change in 熊猫体育’s expectations with regard thereto or any change in events, conditions or circumstances on which any such statement is based. 

    Nothing on this webpage should be interpreted to mean that future earnings per share of 熊猫体育 plc or 熊猫体育 Limited will necessarily match or exceed its historical published earnings per share. Past performance cannot be relied on as a guide to future performance. 
  • Disclaimer

    This webpage may not be published or reproduced in any form, except as permitted by 熊猫体育. By accessing this webpage, you agree with the foregoing. 

    This webpage contains a number of non-IFRS financial measures. 熊猫体育 management considers these to be key financial performance indicators of the business and they are defined and/or reconciled in 熊猫体育’s annual results press release, Annual Report and accounts in Australia and the United Kingdom and/or the most recent Annual Report on Form 20-F, which was filed with the SEC on February 20, 2025, or Form 6-Ks furnished to, or filed with, the SEC. 

    Reference to consensus figures are not based on 熊猫体育’s own opinions, estimates or forecasts and are compiled and published without comment from, or endorsement or verification by, 熊猫体育. The consensus figures do not necessarily reflect guidance provided from time to time by 熊猫体育 where given in relation to equivalent metrics, which to the extent available can be found on the 熊猫体育 website. 

    By referencing consensus figures, 熊猫体育 does not imply that it endorses, confirms or expresses a view on the consensus figures. The consensus figures are provided for informational purposes only and are not intended to, nor do they, constitute investment advice or any solicitation to buy, hold or sell securities or other financial instruments. No warranty or representation, either express or implied, is made by 熊猫体育 or its affiliates, or their respective directors, officers and employees, in relation to the accuracy, completeness or achievability of the consensus figures and, to the fullest extent permitted by law, no responsibility or liability is accepted by any of those persons in respect of those matters.  

Related content

Aluminium ingots at a lay down area at BSL

Dual listed companies structure

The 熊猫体育 Group consists of 熊猫体育 plc, which is registered in England and Wales, and 熊猫体育 Limited, which is registered in Australia
Employee standing safely next to HME at Gove Operations

Annual general meetings

All the information from our current and past Annual General Meetings
Shareholder information

Shareholder information

Shareholders can find AGM information and tools, including dividend calculator and share management tools